Durham University Library Cosin MS V.i.12Ephrem Syrus, etc.
Held by: Durham University Library: Cosin Manuscripts

Manuscript codex containing works of monastic interest, a compound version of Ephraem Syrus's Ad monachos, sermons and homilies on monasticism by Caesarius of Arles and Eusebius of Emesa and an extract from Hugh of Fouilloy's De claustro animae, with two short pieces in Middle English possibly added on blank space. The manuscript is English, possibly written in Norfolk, in the mid 15th century.


Physical description of manuscript
Support

Parchment; quires with flesh-side outermost. Flaying edges, creases and dog-ears on lower corners. Top edges cropped. Untrimmed uneven lower edge and corner in quire 9. Tears to f.29 and 37.

Extent: ii+67+i f
Size: 310 mm x 210 mm

Foliation

Foliated in pencil, 20th century.


Secundo folio: habitauit
Collation

1-88, 94 (wants 2 except stub). Hanna suggests this could be three booklets, dividing after f.49 and 65.

Catchwords: Catchwords on quires 1-8.
Signatures: Quires 1-5 signed a-e, and 8, h.
Layout

Pricking in outer margin, but line-ruling in ink visible on f.11r-v, where there are two rows of pricks; also f.16r-v and elsewhere. Written space 214-6 x 212-7 mm; 39 long lines.

Script

Written in current anglicana, with some secretary forms (g, sometimes single compartment a, mostly as first or last letter of words), expertly. Rubrics by the same hand and red marginalia.

Decoration

Text capitals splashed with red, f.1r-10v, 50r-57v and 68v; with yellow, f.11r-49v and 58r-68r. Paraphs and line fillers in red. Initials, 2 line, red, up to f.57v with flourishing and sometimes infilling in black and sometimes red, including human (f.28r, 40r, 41v, 46v) or animal (f. 36r, 49r) profiles, and a quatrefoil (f.25v).

Corrections and annotation

Many marginal notas and subject indications by main hand in red. In the upper margin of f.41v four lines in red by the main hand, on quiet, starting “Osee. Diues effectus sum & requiem non inueni ... ”. Corrections and subject notes by two italic hands, 16th/17th century. A slip from a 17th century printed English sermon or treatise on Christ's Passion, was found in the volume as a place marker, now tipped on to the front paper flyleaf. Running titles on rectos of item (1) only, in red, giving book number.

Binding

Bound in Durham by Hutchinson, plain calf, 17th century, with double blind fillets for frame and a pair of verticals c. 45 mm from spine. Hutchinson's roll B gilt on board edges. Rebacked in 19th and 21st century; 1 clasp.


Manuscript history
Creation

Written in England, Norfolk?, mid 15th century.

Provenance

Inscription: “Iste liber constat <W>ilhelmo crosse Iste liber pertinett Wilhelmo crosse. Deus est optima rerum & Rosa est pulcherimus florum”, f.1r, with pen trials, later 15th century.Hanna notes a man of this name in Rockland (SW Norfolk) in 1479.
Inscription: “A peece of St Ephreem his workes”, f.1r, by a hand, 16th/17th century, found in other Cosin MSS, not yet identified. “Geo. Davenport. 1664”, on previous pastedown, visible through window cut into present; his list of contents, f.1v. ex-libris and shelf-numbers by Thomas Rud on f.2r.


Manuscript contents
(1a)     f.2r-33v
Original title: Ad monachos
Author: Ephraem, Syrus, Saint, 303-373
Incipit: Dolor me compellit dicere. sed iniquitas mea comminatur michi vt sileam
Explicit: vt omnis anima que hic meditabitur trahatur ad vitam eternam ... Amen. Explicit liber Sextus
Rubric: Iesus Maria. Anna. Incipit liber primus sancti Effrem diaconi qui iuste et perfecte docet vt patet in sequentibus
Language: Latin

Of the various forms in which a part of Ephrem's corpus circulated in Latin translation from the eighth century onwards, this version, in six books, differs from that printed several times. Here the last part of Bk i (f. 4/16 seq.) is the latter part of the Cento ex S. Gregorii homiliis in Evangelia attributed to Ephrem in Berlin MS Theol. Lat. 355 f.31-35; Bk vi cap 2 line 8 is followed (f.11v/7-21v/27) by Bk i cap 10 part - end and all Bk ii, the first part of the Cento ex S. Gregorii ... (f.16r/18-16v/10), and Bk i cap 4 part -10 part. In consequence the six books in this copy correspond to the seven printed, with Bk iii forming Bk ii in this copy.

Cited: Bloomfield, 1727
(1b)     f.25v-31r
Original title: Commonitiuncula ad sororem
Author: ps.-Aldager
Incipit: Admonendus est monachus vt reuerencia habitus sui in actu
Explicit: inter homines tanto viliorum erit ante deum
Rubric: Incipit liber vijus domini Effren diaconi de humilitate vel opere monachorum etc.
Language: Latin

Presented as book vii of (1a). Ascribed to Adalgerus or Albuinus. Found in Hereford Cathedral O.VI.7, where it follows Cosin item (1a), of only six books, and includes (1c) and is further followed by item (2)

Cited: Bloomfield, 6115
(1c)     f.31r-33v
Modern title: Digest of Isidore's, Synonyma
Incipit: Hic introducuntur persone duorum deflentis hominis et admonentis racionis. Homo. Anima mea in angustiis est
Explicit: et diabolus nunquam inueniret locum. vt nobis nocere posset. Hoc ipse nobis prestare dignetur ... Amen
Language: Latin

Digest of Isidore, Synonyma, books I and II. (1a)-(2) occur without attribution and differently arranged in Avignon MS 341, a fifteenth century book from the Avignon Dominicans and in Hereford O.VI.7.

Cited: Bloomfield, 2351
(2)     f.33v-36r
Original title: Cento ex S. Gregorii homiliis
Incipit: Si nolumus timere deum in tranquillitate. timeamus attricti percussionibus eius venturum iudicium
Explicit: quomodo non erimus dignis flagellis et diuersis tormentis qui pleni sumus peccatis. De quibus non redemit ipse qui v.et r.i.s.s. Amen. Iesus. Maria. Anna.
Rubric: Iesus. Maria. Anna. Tractatus ex omelijs beati Gregorij pape.
Language: Latin

Other versions, in twelfth century copies, both following the same text as here: Paris, B.N. MS lat. 3007 f.40-42 (lacks the passage here f.34v/11-35v/31) and lat. 3454 f.3r-4r; also Avignon MS 341 (15th century); Hereford Cathedral O.VI.7 (end of 14th century) art. 17 (a-c) has only the first three homilies of this manuscript, then others, of which Hereford art.17(h) is Cosin item (4a).

(3a)     f.36r-37v
Original title: Sermo ad monachos
Author: Caesarius, of Arles, Saint, 470?-542
Incipit: Dominis sanctis et in Christo desiderandis fratribus in blagiacensi monasterio
Explicit: ad portum vere felicitatis supplicantibus vobis adiuuante Christo domino peruenire cui est honor et gloria in secula seculorum Amen
Rubric: Incipiunt sermones sancti Cesarij Episcopi
Language: Latin
Edited: Caesarius, ii, 925-931
(3b)     f.37v-38v
Original title: Sermo ad monachos
Author: Eusebius, Bishop of Emesa, approximately 300-approximately 359
Incipit: Ad hunc locum karissimi non ad quietem non ad securitatem sed ad pugnam certamenque conuenimus
Explicit: vt terrori fit coniuncta consolacio. Cruenti quidem est quod frendet sed victi est quod tabescit
Rubric: Item alius sermo sancti Cesarij Episcopi
Language: Latin

The omission of the final few sentences occurs in other English copies, e.g. London British Library MSS Royal 5.E.ix f.65v, 5.F.x f.7v, 8.D.viii f.84r.

Edited: Eusebius, sermones, 861-868
(3c)     f.38v-40r
Original title: Sermo ad monachos
Author: Caesarius, of Arles, Saint, 470?-542
Incipit: Quod supplicato patre vestro et caritate iubente fraternitati vestre qualemcumque sermonem profero
Explicit: saltem vobis orantibus peccatorum venia tribuatur Amen
Rubric: Item alius sermo sancti Cesarij Episcopi
Language: Latin
Edited: Caesarius, ii, 936-939
(3d)     f.40r-49v
Original title: Homeliae ad monachos
Author: Eusebius, Bishop of Emesa, approximately 300-approximately 359
Incipit: Exhortatur nos fratres sermo diuinus vt curramus dum lucem habemus
Explicit: in presenti vita ornamentum sitis et in futura presidium Amen
Rubric: Hic incipiunt Omelie Eusebij Emiseni exortatoris
Language: Latin

Homilies i-vi, viii, vii (part), ix. Other copies of these homilies, e.g. Hereford O.VI.7 art. 21 occur together with item (4).

Edited: Eusebius, homiliarum, 419-491, 511-516, 500-505, 522-529.
(4a)     f.49v-52v
Original title: De tribus habitaculis animae
Author: Patrick, Bishop of Dublin, -1084
Incipit: Tria sunt sub omnipotentis dei manu habitacula.
Explicit: sine fastidio clamore cordis laudabunt deum omnipotentem benignum misericordem Cui honor ... Amen
Rubric: De tribus habitaculis. celeste. terrestre. et infernale
Language: Latin

This copy is not mentioned in Gwynn's edition; from the readings listed (p. 24) it can be assigned to the earlier recension (p. 47). Several other copies, e.g. BL Royal 5.E.ix, 5.F.x and Hereford O.I.6, contain homilies attributed to Caesarius and Eusebius, including the same eleven as item (3), with the same attributions.

(4b)     f.52v
Modern title: Prayer
Incipit: O Iesu clementissime fac nos impleri opere Quod donasti scribere litterali serie Amen.
Explicit: Iesu fili dei tu miserere mei. Laus ex ore laus ex corde laus ex opere auctori laudis Amen.
Language: Latin
(5)     f.52v-65r
Original title: De claustro animae (extract)
Author: Hugh, of Fouilloy, -1172 or 1173
Incipit: Duodecim sunt abusiones claustri. quibus tota religionis summa corrumpitur. idest. Prelatus necligens
Explicit: Ex hiijs igitur obseruancie mandatis. pendet summa tocius religionis. Explicit tractatus Magistri hugonis de sancto victore de xij abusionibus claustri.
Rubric: Iesus Maria Anna. De duodecim abusionibus claustri etc.
Language: Latin

Book 2 cap. xi-xxiii; here, as commonly, attributed to Hugh of St Victor. In this copy chapters 8 & 9 (i.e. xix & xx in full work) divide at “ructus ingurgitati ventris Miserabilior inter alias abusiones”.

Cited: Bloomfield, 1640
(6)     f.65r
Modern title: Couplet on the eucharist
Incipit: Hit semeth whiȝth
Explicit: in his godhed Da fidem domine
Language: English, Middle (1100-1500)

Written in red. For another version, see Cosin MS V.v.19, f.72v-73r

Cited: NIMEV, 1640
(7)     f.65v
Original title: De natura apice
Author: Rolle, Richard, 1290?-1349
Incipit: The Be hath þre kyndes. One is þat he is never ydel
Explicit: veyne thowghtis
Rubric: Ihesus Maria Anna. De natura apice
Language: English, Middle (1100-1500)

The only other known copy, one in a sequence entitled "Moralia Ricardi heremite" is in Lincoln Cathedral 91 (by Robert Thornton, E.R.Yorks, mid 15th century). The Cosin spellings (ar, arn, mekel, whilke) suggest S.Lincs. or NW Norfolk. Hanna infers SCentral or SE Norfolk from the linguistic evidence.

Edited: Allen, 54-55 (from Thornton ms)
(8)     f.66r-68v
Modern title: On sin

A collection of short extracts on sins and their remedies

(8a)     f.66r-66v
Incipit: Tria sunt peccata ex quibus omnia fere peccata originalia vel actualia orta sunt videlicet
Explicit: In terciis nullos
Language: Latin
(8b)     f.66v
Incipit: De recordatione diuersorum domorum dei. Recordare debet unusquique quod deus contulit sibi gratiam baptismalem
Explicit: Superiora ad patrocinium
Language: Latin

domorum corrected to donorum, 17th century

(8c)     f.66v-67r
Incipit: De recordacione passionis cristi. Recogitare debemus Quis est qui patitur
Explicit: Grandi piaculo. Difficili medicamento.
Language: Latin

Leaf lost between 66 and 67, possibly affecting text.

(8d)     f.67r-67v
Incipit: De modo contemplando deum. Cogita quod deus est supra omnia sensibilia
Explicit: summa caritas inuenitur
Language: Latin

contemplando corrected to contemplandi, 17th century

(8e)     f.67v-68r
Incipit: De amore erga deum. Bernardus. Dominus in cruce moriens in singulis membris dolorem
Explicit: ab eius vindicta etc
Language: Latin
(8f)     f.68r
Incipit: De septem peccatis mortalibus. De superbia que est amor proprie excellencie
Explicit: horror et desperacio futuri
Language: Latin
(8g)     f.68r-68v
Incipit: De remediis contra peccata mortalia. Gregorius. Per timorem dei sumus humiles contra superbiam
Explicit: sapienciam maturi contra leuitatem luxurie
Language: Latin
(8h)     f.68v
Incipit: Albertus. Septem vicia curantur passione christi. Nam capitis inclinatio in cruce curat superbiam
Explicit: vestium crucifixioribus hec curant auariciam etc.
Language: Latin

Microfilm
Microfilmed in 1985/86 by the Hill Monastic Manuscript Library, St John's Abbey and University, Collegeville, Minnesota. Copies held by them and Durham University Library.

Bibliography

English writings of Richard Rolle   OCLC citation, ed. Allen, H. E. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1931)

Bloomfield, Morton W., Guyot, Bertrand-Georges, Howard, Donald R. and Kabealo, Thyra B., Incipits of Latin works on the virtues and vices, 1100-1500 A.D. Including a section of incipits of works on the Pater noster   OCLC citation (Cambridge, Mass.: Mediaeval Academy of America, 1979)

Catalogi veteres librorum Ecclesiae cathedralis dunelm. Catalogues of the library of Durham cathedral, at various periods, from the conquest to the dissolution, including catalogues of the library of the abbey of Hulne, and of the mss.   OCLC citation, Surtees Society 7, (London: J.B. Nichols and Son, [1838]).

Eusebius Gallicanus. Collectio homiliarum   OCLC citation, ed. Leroy, J., Corpus Christianorum., Series Latina, 101A, (Turnhout: Brepols, 1971)

Eusebius Gallicanus. Sermones extravagantes   OCLC citation, ed. Glorie, F., Corpus Christianorum., Series Latina, 101B, (Turnhout: Brepols, 1971)

Gwynn, A., Patrick Bishop og Dublin. The writings of Bishop Patrick 1074-1084   OCLC citation, v.1 (Dublin: Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, 1955)

Newhauser, R. and Bejzcy, I., A supplement to Morton W. Bloomfield et al. Incipits of Latin works on the virtues and vices, 1100-1500 A.D.   OCLC citation (Turnhout: Brepols, 2008)

A new index of middle English verse   OCLC citation, ed. J. Boffey & A. S. G. Edwards (London: British Library, 2005)

Richard Rolle Uncollected prose and verse with related northern texts   OCLC citation, ed. Hanna, R., EETS OS 329 (Oxford: OUP, 2007)

Sancti Caesarii Arelatensis sermones: nunc primum in unum collecti et ad leges artis criticae ex innumeris mss. recogniti   OCLC citation, ed. Morin, G., Corpus Christianorum., Series Latina, 103-104, (Turnhout: Brepols, 1953)

Index terms